← Back to News

IRS Approves Alternative Basis Recovery Method for Contingent Payment Installment Sale

453-1(c)(7)(ii), allowing the trust to recover its basis at twice the rate of the normal ratable method.

Case: PLR-102769-26
Court: IRS Written Determination
Opinion Date: November 20, 2026
Published: Nov 20, 2026
IRS_WRITTEN_DETERMINATION

IRS Greenlights Alternative Basis Recovery for Trust’s Contingent Payment Sale

The IRS has approved a trust’s request to use an alternative basis recovery method under Treasury Regulation § 15A.453-1(c)(7)(ii), allowing the trust to recover its basis at twice the rate of the normal ratable method. In a rare move, the IRS granted the taxpayer’s pre-filing ruling request before the Year 1 tax return due date, signaling its willingness to accommodate unconventional—but well-documented—contingent payment structures.

The trust, which sold Company stock through a contingent payment sale tied to future EBITDA performance, sought permission to accelerate basis recovery to better match its economic expectations. The IRS’s approval hinged on the trust’s ability to demonstrate that the normal ratable basis recovery method—which spreads basis recovery proportionally over all payments—would not "clearly reflect income" under the circumstances. The decision underscores the IRS’s openness to tailored solutions when taxpayers provide robust financial projections and historical performance data to justify an alternative approach.

Trust’s Contingent Payment Sale: Earnouts Tied to EBITDA

The trust, a cash-method taxpayer filing on a calendar-year basis, held an A% stake in Company, an S corporation engaged in commodity products manufacturing. On Date 1, the trust and affiliated shareholders sold all Company stock in a transaction structured as an installment sale under IRC § 453. The purchase agreement provided for an initial payment of $a at closing in Year 1, followed by four uncapped earnout payments due on the successive anniversaries of Date 1 in Years 2 through 5.

The earnout payments were contingent on Company’s EBITDA performance, with the first two payments (Years 2 and 3) calculated as B% of EBITDA exceeding $b, and the latter two payments (Years 4 and 5) calculated as B% of EBITDA exceeding $c. Based on Company’s historical EBITDA and internal financial projections, the trust anticipated receiving little, if any, earnout payments in Years 2 and 3. The estimated earnout payments allocable to the trust were projected at $d for Year 2, $e for Year 3, $f for Year 4, and $g for Year 5, resulting in a total estimated purchase price of $h.

Normal Basis Recovery Rule vs. Taxpayer’s Proposal: A Stark Contrast

The normal basis recovery rule under Treas. Reg. § 15A.453-1(c)(3)(i) governs how taxpayers must allocate basis in contingent payment sales when the total selling price is uncertain. Under this rule, basis—including selling expenses—is allocated equally across each taxable year in which a payment may be received, regardless of the actual payment amounts. This approach treats the five-year payment period as a fixed schedule, with $j of basis allocated to each year (Years 1–5), irrespective of whether payments materialize. The regulation explicitly states that if no payment is received or the payment is less than the allocated basis for a given year, no loss is recognized unless it is the final payment year. Any unrecovered basis is then carried forward to the next year.

The implications of this rigid allocation are stark. As demonstrated in Scenario 1, the taxpayer’s $j basis allocation in Year 1 would exceed the projected payment of $q, resulting in a disproportionately large gain recognition in Year 1 due to the mismatch between basis recovery and actual cash flow. Conversely, in Year 5, the taxpayer would face a disproportionately large loss because the final $j basis allocation would exceed the projected payment of $g, leaving little to no basis recovery despite the payment. This outcome arises from the regulation’s requirement to spread basis evenly across all five years, even when payments are skewed toward later years.

The taxpayer proposed an alternative method under Treas. Reg. § 15A.453-1(c)(7)(ii), arguing that the normal rule would “substantially and inappropriately defer recovery of basis.” Their method allocates basis proportionally to each installment payment, based on the ratio of the payment to the total estimated payments ($h). Under this approach, the allocated basis for each year would reflect the actual economic reality of the earnout structure. As shown in Scenario 2, the basis allocations ($l for Year 1, $m for Year 2, $n for Year 3, $o for Year 4, and $p for Year 5) align with the projected payments ($q, $d, $e, $f, and $g, respectively), avoiding the distortions created by the normal rule. The taxpayer contended this method would allow them to recover basis at twice the rate of the normal rule, thereby more accurately matching income recognition with cash flow.

IRS Approves Alternative Method: Why the Facts Mattered

The IRS’s approval hinged on two statutory requirements under § 15A.453-1(c)(7)(ii): the taxpayer’s alternative basis recovery method must be both reasonable and ratable, and it must recover basis at least twice as fast as the normal rule. The agency’s analysis turned on the company’s historical EBITDA performance and verifiable future earnings estimates, not speculative projections.

The taxpayer’s proposal allocated basis in direct proportion to the projected earnout payments ($q in Year 1, $d in Year 2, $e in Year 3, $f in Year 4, and $g in Year 5), ensuring the recovery matched the actual cash flow timing. The IRS emphasized that the projections were grounded in contemporaneous financial data—including the company’s historical EBITDA trends and third-party earnings forecasts—rather than hypothetical scenarios. As the ruling noted, the method avoided the distortions of the normal rule, which would have deferred $k of unrecovered basis until Year 5, creating a disproportionate gain in Year 1 and an outsized loss in the final year.

Critically, the taxpayer demonstrated that its alternative method would recover basis at twice the rate of the normal rule, satisfying the regulatory threshold. The IRS concluded that the approach clearly reflected income by aligning basis recovery with the economic reality of the earnout structure, where payments were tied to measurable performance metrics. The agency’s reliance on auditable financial data—not projections alone—was the decisive factor in granting the PLR.

What This PLR Means for Taxpayers in Contingent Payment Sales

The IRS’s approval in PLR-102769-26 signals a narrow but meaningful opening for taxpayers whose contingent payment sales—particularly earnouts tied to verifiable financial metrics like EBITDA—do not align with the default ratable basis recovery method under Treasury Regulation §15A.453-1(c)(3)(i). The agency’s conclusion hinged on the taxpayer’s ability to demonstrate that its alternative method would recover basis at twice the rate of the normal rule while clearly reflecting income, a threshold met by aligning basis recovery with the economic reality of the earnout structure. Crucially, the IRS emphasized the use of auditable financial data—historical EBITDA and earnings estimates—rather than speculative projections, which insulated the method from challenge.

For other taxpayers in similar positions, this PLR underscores that the IRS may entertain alternative basis recovery methods when the normal rule fails to capture the timing of income recognition accurately. Taxpayers with earnouts tied to EBITDA or other measurable performance metrics, minimal early payments, and a demonstrated ability to support their method with verifiable financial data may find this ruling instructive. However, the IRS’s reasoning remains fact-specific, and the ruling itself is non-precedential under Section 6110(k)(3) of the Code. Taxpayers should not cite PLR-102769-26 as authority but may use its reasoning to bolster a request for a similar ruling tailored to their facts.

To comply with IRS requirements, taxpayers relying on this or a comparable PLR must attach a copy of the letter to the relevant tax return or, if filing electronically, include a statement with the date and control number of the ruling. Given the IRS’s heightened scrutiny of contingent payment structures, advance rulings remain the safest path to certainty for taxpayers seeking to deviate from the normal basis recovery rules.

News summaries on this site are generated with the assistance of artificial intelligence from primary source documents and are provided for educational purposes only. They are not legal advice and may contain errors; consult a qualified tax attorney about your situation and rely on the original source document. Communications are not protected by attorney client privilege until such relationship with an attorney is formed.

Original Source Document

202645012.pdfView PDF

PLR-102769-26 - Full Opinion

Download PDF

Loading PDF...

Related Cases