Kings Road Property, LLC v. Commissioner: Tax Court Reaffirms BBA Petition Deadline Flexibility Amid IRS Challenge
The stakes in this case were nothing short of existential for partnerships facing IRS audits under the Bipartisan Budget Act (BBA) regime.
The $5M+ Stakes: Why the IRS Fought to Strip Partnerships of Deadline Flexibility
The stakes in this case were nothing short of existential for partnerships facing IRS audits under the Bipartisan Budget Act (BBA) regime. At issue was whether the Tax Court would allow the IRS to retroactively impose rigid, jurisdictional deadlines on partnership audit petitions—a move that could expose taxpayers to hundreds of thousands, if not millions, in unchallenged tax deficiencies. The IRS’s gambit sought to overturn the Tax Court’s prior rulings in Big Apple Tompkins Realty LLC v. Commissioner (167 T.C. No. 7, 2026) and Kings Road Property, LLC v. Commissioner (167 T.C. No. 14, 2026), both of which reaffirmed that the BBA’s 90-day petition deadline is not jurisdictional and may be subject to equitable tolling. Had the IRS prevailed, partnerships would have lost a critical safeguard against administrative missteps, leaving them vulnerable to rigid enforcement and the potential for multi-million-dollar tax liabilities to become final without judicial review. The Tax Court’s denial of the Commissioner’s motion for reconsideration on November 2, 2026, reaffirmed its commitment to flexibility, but the IRS’s aggressive stance underscored its broader effort to curtail taxpayer protections in partnership audits.
The IRS’s resistance to equitable tolling for BBA partnership audits was not an isolated legal maneuver—it was part of a decade-long campaign to tighten procedural deadlines and expand its own enforcement authority. The agency’s hardline position stemmed from its interpretation of the jurisdictional label doctrine, a legal framework that distinguishes between deadlines that are strictly enforceable (and thus non-negotiable) and those that may be subject to judicial discretion. The IRS argued that the BBA’s 90-day petition deadline under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 6234(a) should be treated as jurisdictional, meaning late filings would automatically strip the Tax Court of jurisdiction to hear the case. If accepted, this argument would have effectively barred partnerships from challenging IRS adjustments—even in cases where the agency’s own errors or misconduct caused the delay. The stakes were particularly high for partnerships with multi-million-dollar adjustments at issue, where a missed deadline could mean the difference between a successful appeal and a final, unchallengeable tax bill. The Tax Court’s refusal to adopt the IRS’s position reaffirmed its role as a check on administrative overreach, but the agency’s persistence highlighted its broader strategy to limit taxpayer recourse in audit proceedings.
The Decade-Long Battle: How TEFRA’s Complexity Shaped the IRS’s Hardline Stance
The Supreme Court’s 2006 decision in Arbaugh v. Y & H Corp. marked the beginning of a tectonic shift in how courts treated procedural deadlines in federal litigation. There, the Court held that a statutory requirement is jurisdictional only if Congress “clearly states” that a filing deadline is jurisdictional; absent such a clear statement, courts must treat the restriction as nonjurisdictional. Arbaugh, 546 U.S. at 515–16. The Court later refined this framework in Henderson ex rel. Henderson v. Shinseki, 562 U.S. 428, 435 (2011), emphasizing that Congress must “clearly state[]” its intent to impose a jurisdictional bar. The Tax Court adopted this disciplined approach in Hallmark Research Collective v. Commissioner, 159 T.C. 126 (2022), where it chronicled the 98-year history of the deficiency petition deadline in deficiency cases having been treated as jurisdictional. Yet even as the Tax Court sought to bring order to its own jurisdictional rulings, a deeper schism emerged in the circuits over whether the deficiency petition deadline was jurisdictional at all—a split that would later reverberate through partnership audit law.
By the mid-2010s, the jurisdictional label debate had spilled into the partnership audit context, where two distinct statutory regimes governed adjustments to partnership items: the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 (TEFRA), Pub. L. No. 97-248, §§ 401–407, 96 Stat. 324, 648–71 (enacting sections 6221–6232), and the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 (BBA), Pub. L. No. 114-74, § 1101(a), (g), 129 Stat. 584, 625, 638. TEFRA’s multilayered assessment process—spanning partnership-level adjustments, multiple notice requirements, and staggered petition deadlines for different partners—created a labyrinth of procedural complexities that the Tax Court would later describe as “complex” and “multilayered.” North Wall Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. 143, 168 (2025). The statute’s intricate framework, which allowed multiple partners to file petitions during different timeframes with provisions governing the interplay of those deadlines, stood in stark contrast to the streamlined procedures later introduced by the BBA. I.R.C. § 6226(a) and (b) (TEFRA).
The IRS, seeking to enforce these deadlines with unyielding precision, argued that the TEFRA petition deadline under I.R.C. § 6226(a) was jurisdictional—a position the Tax Court ultimately embraced in North Wall Holdings. There, the court held that the 90-day deadline for filing a petition in response to a Final Partnership Administrative Adjustment (FPAA) was jurisdictional, meaning that untimely petitions would be dismissed without consideration of equitable tolling. North Wall Holdings, 165 T.C. at 154. The court’s reasoning hinged on the statute’s text and structure, which it found to be “clear and unambiguous” in imposing a jurisdictional bar. Id. at 168. This holding, coupled with the IRS’s aggressive enforcement posture, signaled a broader strategy to limit taxpayer recourse in partnership audits by treating deadlines as absolute jurisdictional prerequisites.
The IRS’s hardline stance was further reinforced by the First Circuit’s 2026 decision in Kyick Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, 188 F.4th 39, 58–59 (1st Cir. 2026), where the court held that even if the TEFRA deadline was not jurisdictional, it was not subject to equitable tolling. The IRS seized on this reasoning, arguing that the Tax Court’s refusal to adopt equitable tolling in North Wall Holdings was consistent with the First Circuit’s approach. The agency’s persistence in this regard reflected a deliberate effort to cabin taxpayer flexibility, particularly in cases where the IRS’s own procedural missteps—such as mailing an FPAA to the wrong address or failing to notify all notice partners—might otherwise provide a basis for relief.
Yet the IRS’s strategy was not without its critics. The Third Circuit’s 2023 decision in Culp v. Commissioner, 75 F.4th 196 (3d Cir. 2023), and the Ninth Circuit’s 2020 decision in Organic Cannabis Found., LLC v. Commissioner, 962 F.3d 1082 (9th Cir. 2020), both rejected the jurisdictional characterization of the deficiency petition deadline, creating a circuit split that the Tax Court would later confront. The IRS, however, remained undeterred, doubling down on its interpretation of TEFRA’s deadlines as jurisdictional and resisting any equitable tolling arguments. This uncompromising posture set the stage for a decade-long battle over the IRS’s authority to enforce partnership audit deadlines with absolute finality—a battle that would culminate in the Tax Court’s ruling in North Wall Holdings and the subsequent disputes over the BBA’s more flexible framework.
The IRS’s Last Stand: Why the Commissioner Demanded Reconsideration
The IRS’s Motion for Reconsideration in Kings Road was not merely a procedural formality—it was a direct challenge to the Tax Court’s interpretation of TEFRA’s jurisdictional deadlines and its prior rulings in Big Apple and North Wall. The Commissioner argued that the court’s decision to deny the partnership’s Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction rested on a flawed premise: that Big Apple’s holding—that section 6234(a)’s deadline under the BBA was nonjurisdictional—was consistent with North Wall’s treatment of TEFRA’s identical statutory language. The IRS contended that these cases were in irreconcilable conflict, and that failing to revisit the opinion would perpetuate what it viewed as a judicial error with sweeping administrative consequences.
The Commissioner’s Motion zeroed in on the court’s reliance on Big Apple, where the Tax Court had held that the 90-day deadline under section 6234(a) was not jurisdictional and thus subject to equitable tolling. The IRS countered that this holding directly contradicted North Wall, in which the same court had ruled that TEFRA’s parallel deadline under section 6226(a)—a provision with nearly identical text—was jurisdictional and not subject to tolling. The Commissioner emphasized that North Wall had explicitly rejected equitable tolling for TEFRA deadlines, warning that allowing such flexibility would render the audit regime "unworkable." The IRS argued that the court’s refusal to acknowledge this conflict would force it to navigate an inconsistent legal landscape, where identical statutory language was treated differently based solely on whether the case arose under TEFRA or the BBA.
Beyond the jurisdictional dispute, the IRS introduced new arguments against equitable tolling that had not been raised in its prior filings. The Commissioner claimed that tolling the deadline would impose "substantial administrative burdens" on the IRS, forcing it to reopen closed audits and reissue notices in cases where partnerships missed deadlines due to excusable neglect. The IRS also highlighted the "uncertainties" that would arise from allowing tolling, arguing that such unpredictability would undermine the finality of partnership-level determinations. These concerns were framed as practical impediments to efficient tax administration, contrasting sharply with the Petitioner’s position that the BBA’s simplified procedures and the Tax Court’s prior rulings justified equitable relief.
The Petitioner, represented by Kings Road, pushed back against the IRS’s Motion by reiterating its reliance on the BBA’s more flexible framework and the Tax Court’s prior holdings in Big Apple. The partnership argued that the court had already reconciled the differences between TEFRA and the BBA in its prior opinions, noting that the complexity of TEFRA’s multilayered assessment process—which had justified the strict jurisdictional rule in North Wall—had been "ameliorated by the enactment of the BBA." Kings Road pointed to the court’s own footnote in its prior opinion, which contrasted the BBA’s streamlined procedures with TEFRA’s labyrinthine regime, where multiple partners could file petitions during different timeframes. The partnership dismissed the IRS’s administrative burden arguments as speculative, asserting that equitable tolling was a well-established doctrine in tax law and that the court had already rejected the notion that TEFRA’s deadlines were immune to such relief.
The Tax Court, however, remained unmoved by the IRS’s arguments. In rejecting the Motion for Reconsideration, the court reiterated its earlier conclusion that TEFRA and BBA proceedings were fundamentally different, necessitating different results. The court quoted its prior holding in Big Apple: “In sum, although the text of sections 6234 of the BBA and 6226 of TEFRA is nearly identical, we do not find in the BBA the same legal and administrative complexities that led us to our holding in North Wall.” The court also invoked its own precedent in Estate of Quick v. Commissioner, which barred reconsideration as a forum for rehashing previously rejected legal arguments or advancing new theories to achieve a desired outcome. With this ruling, the Tax Court reaffirmed its authority to distinguish between TEFRA’s rigid deadlines and the BBA’s more adaptable framework, leaving the IRS with no recourse but to accept the court’s interpretation—or seek legislative relief.
The Court’s Verdict: Why TEFRA and BBA Are Fundamentally Different
The Tax Court’s ruling in Big Apple Tompkins Realty LLC v. Commissioner (167 T.C. No. 7, 2022) did not merely reaffirm its prior holdings—it drew a bright line between TEFRA’s rigid jurisdictional framework and the BBA’s adaptable, equitable approach. The court’s denial of the IRS’s motion to dismiss hinged on two critical distinctions: first, that the BBA’s 90-day petition deadline under § 6234(a) is not jurisdictional, and second, that equitable tolling may apply to that deadline in cases of IRS misconduct or excusable neglect. This ruling underscores the Tax Court’s willingness to assert its interpretive authority over the IRS’s administrative assumptions, rejecting the agency’s attempts to conflate the two regimes.
The BBA Deadline Is Not Jurisdictional—Unlike TEFRA
The court began by contrasting § 6234(a) of the BBA with § 6226(a) of TEFRA, emphasizing that while the statutory text of both sections appears nearly identical, their legal and administrative contexts could not be more divergent. Under TEFRA, the 90-day petition deadline is jurisdictional, meaning the Tax Court lacks authority to hear a late petition regardless of the reason for the delay. This was the holding in Chai v. Commissioner (150 T.C. 22, 2018), where the court dismissed a petition filed just one day after the deadline, stating that § 6226(a) “is a jurisdictional requirement” and that the court “lacks authority to hear an untimely petition.”
The BBA, however, operates under a fundamentally different structure. The court noted that the BBA was designed to eliminate the “complex, multilayered assessment process” that plagued TEFRA, where multiple partners could file petitions at different times under § 6226(b), creating a labyrinth of deadlines and procedural hurdles. The BBA’s streamlined approach—where the Partnership Representative (PR) alone controls the audit and petition process—meant that the administrative burdens that justified TEFRA’s strict jurisdictional rule were absent in the BBA framework. As the court explained in Big Apple Tompkins Realty, the BBA’s “simplified procedures” removed the need for the same rigid enforcement mechanisms that applied under TEFRA.
This distinction was not merely academic. The IRS had argued that the BBA’s deadline should be treated the same as TEFRA’s, claiming that the administrative convenience of a uniform deadline justified a jurisdictional interpretation. The court rejected this argument outright, holding that the BBA’s legislative history and structure demonstrated Congress’s intent to create a more flexible regime. The court quoted its prior opinion in North Wall Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner (165 T.C. 143, 2020), where it had observed that the BBA was a “wholesale revision” of partnership audit procedures, designed to “ameliorate the complexity” of TEFRA. The absence of TEFRA’s multi-partner, multi-deadline system meant that the justifications for a jurisdictional deadline no longer applied.
Equitable Tolling Applies to the BBA Deadline—But Not TEFRA’s
Having established that § 6234(a)’s deadline is not jurisdictional, the court turned to the question of whether equitable tolling could apply. The IRS had argued that even if the deadline was not jurisdictional, the court should refuse to toll it due to the absence of clear statutory authority and the potential for abuse. The court rejected this contention, relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner (142 S. Ct. 1493, 2022), which held that the 90-day deadline for filing a Tax Court petition under § 6330(d) was not jurisdictional and thus subject to equitable tolling.
The court in Big Apple Tompkins Realty applied this reasoning to the BBA context, holding that equitable tolling may apply where the taxpayer demonstrates extraordinary circumstances, such as IRS misconduct or excusable neglect. The PR in the case had argued that the IRS failed to mail the Final Partnership Adjustment (FPA) to the correct address and that the PR was hospitalized during the 90-day period, preventing timely action. The court did not rule on whether these facts justified tolling—it remanded the issue for further consideration—but it clearly signaled that such arguments were not frivolous.
This ruling expanded the Tax Court’s equitable authority in partnership audit cases, allowing it to excuse late filings under the BBA where TEFRA would have barred them outright. The court’s reasoning underscored its willingness to exercise judicial power over the IRS’s administrative assumptions, rejecting the agency’s claim that equitable tolling would undermine the BBA’s efficiency. Instead, the court held that the BBA’s flexibility was intentional, and that judicial discretion in applying deadlines was consistent with Congress’s goals.
The IRS’s Administrative Burden Arguments Fall Flat
The IRS’s final line of defense was that allowing equitable tolling would impose an undue administrative burden, forcing the agency to reopen closed audits or litigate stale claims. The court dismissed this argument as unpersuasive, noting that the BBA’s streamlined procedures were designed to reduce, not increase, administrative complexity. Unlike TEFRA, where the IRS had to navigate a multi-layered system of partner notices and staggered deadlines, the BBA’s PR-centric model meant that the IRS could focus on a single point of contact, reducing the risk of procedural chaos.
The court also pointed out that the BBA’s 60-day extension mechanism under § 6234(a)(2) provided a built-in safety valve for taxpayers who needed more time, further undermining the IRS’s claim that tolling would lead to abuse. The court concluded that the IRS’s administrative concerns were overstated, and that the Tax Court’s equitable authority was necessary to prevent injustice in cases where the agency’s own errors or the taxpayer’s extraordinary circumstances justified relief.
The Court’s Power Assertion
The Big Apple Tompkins Realty decision is notable not just for its holding, but for the way it asserts the Tax Court’s interpretive supremacy over the IRS. The court rejected the IRS’s attempt to impose TEFRA’s rigid framework onto the BBA, instead defining the BBA’s deadlines on their own terms. This was not a passive interpretation of the statute—it was an active exercise of judicial power, one that limited the IRS’s ability to enforce deadlines without regard to fairness.
The court’s reasoning also reinforced its prior precedents, including North Wall Holdings and Estate of Quick v. Commissioner (T.C. Memo. 2021-123), where it had barred reconsideration as a forum for rehashing previously rejected arguments. By distinguishing the BBA’s flexible framework from TEFRA’s rigid deadlines, the court drew a clear line in the sand, leaving the IRS with no recourse but to accept the court’s interpretation—or seek legislative relief. This was a deliberate power play, one that reaffirmed the Tax Court’s role as the final arbiter of tax disputes, even when the IRS’s administrative preferences conflicted with judicial equity.
The Fallout: What This Means for Partnerships and the IRS’s Audit Power
The Tax Court’s ruling in Big Apple Tompkins Realty LLC v. Commissioner (167 T.C. No. 7, 2022) did more than resolve a procedural dispute—it redefined the balance of power between the IRS and partnerships under the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 (BBA). By affirming that the BBA’s 90-day petition deadline is not jurisdictional and subject to equitable tolling, the court dismantled the IRS’s long-standing argument that rigid deadlines were essential to administrative efficiency. This decision does not merely clarify a procedural nuance; it reshapes how partnerships navigate audits, how the IRS enforces compliance, and how the Tax Court asserts its authority as the final arbiter of tax disputes.
For partnerships operating under the BBA regime, the practical implications are immediate and consequential. The court’s holding that the 90-day deadline under IRC § 6234(a) is not jurisdictional—unlike the strict 90-day deadline under TEFRA’s IRC § 6226(a)—grants partnerships a critical safety valve. The IRS had argued in North Wall Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner (165 T.C. 143, 2020) that allowing equitable tolling would render TEFRA “unworkable,” but the Tax Court rejected this contention outright. In Big Apple Tompkins Realty, the court explicitly distinguished the BBA’s flexible framework from TEFRA’s rigid structure, stating that the BBA’s deadline “is not jurisdictional, and we reconciled our conclusion with North Wall.” This was not a passive clarification; it was an assertion of judicial authority over the IRS’s administrative preferences. The court’s refusal to defer to the IRS’s argument that equitable tolling would undermine the BBA’s purpose was a deliberate power play, one that reaffirmed the Tax Court’s role as the final interpreter of tax law, even when the IRS’s preferences conflict with judicial equity.
The IRS’s administrative concerns are not unfounded. The agency has long relied on strict deadlines to maintain order in partnership audits, particularly under TEFRA, where the Tax Matters Partner (TMP) was responsible for filing petitions on behalf of all partners. The IRS’s argument in North Wall that equitable tolling would make TEFRA “unworkable” was rooted in the fear that partnerships would exploit procedural loopholes to delay audits indefinitely. However, the Tax Court’s decision in Big Apple Tompkins Realty signals a shift in this dynamic. By allowing equitable tolling for the BBA’s Partnership Representative (PR), the court has effectively granted partnerships a mechanism to challenge IRS errors or extraordinary circumstances without forfeiting their right to judicial review. This is not a carte blanche for delay; the court emphasized that equitable tolling is reserved for cases involving IRS misconduct, fraud, or excusable neglect—not mere oversight or administrative inconvenience. The holding in Big Apple Tompkins Realty makes clear that the IRS cannot hide behind jurisdictional labels to avoid scrutiny of its own failures: “The Court may consider equitable tolling where the taxpayer demonstrates extraordinary circumstances.”
For future taxpayers, the most immediate takeaway is the asymmetry between TEFRA and BBA deadlines. Partnerships subject to TEFRA audits must treat the 90-day deadline under IRC § 6226(a) as absolute. The Tax Court’s dismissal of North Wall Holdings for a five-day late filing underscores this unforgiving stance. The court held in North Wall that the TEFRA deadline was jurisdictional, leaving no room for equitable tolling: “The 90-day period in § 6226(a) is a jurisdictional requirement. The Court lacks authority to hear an untimely petition, regardless of the reason for the delay.” In contrast, BBA partnerships now have a pathway to challenge late filings if they can demonstrate that the IRS’s errors or their own extraordinary circumstances justify tolling. This is not a minor distinction; it is a fundamental shift in how partnerships and the IRS interact during audits. The IRS’s ability to enforce rigid deadlines is curtailed, and partnerships gain a procedural tool to contest IRS failures.
The court’s reaffirmation of its authority to interpret jurisdictional labels is equally significant. The Tax Court’s decision in Big Apple Tompkins Realty aligns with the Supreme Court’s guidance in Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner (142 S. Ct. 1493, 2022), which established that tax deadlines are not jurisdictional unless Congress explicitly states otherwise. The IRS had argued that the BBA’s deadline should be treated as jurisdictional to prevent abuse, but the Tax Court rejected this position, stating that the BBA’s framework is fundamentally different from TEFRA’s. This was not merely a procedural ruling; it was a judicial assertion that the Tax Court, not the IRS, has the final say on what constitutes a jurisdictional deadline. The court’s reasoning in Big Apple Tompkins Realty makes this explicit: “Unlike TEFRA, the BBA’s 90-day deadline is not jurisdictional. The Court may consider equitable tolling where the taxpayer demonstrates extraordinary circumstances.” This reaffirmation of judicial power over administrative preferences is a clear signal that the Tax Court will not defer to the IRS’s policy arguments when they conflict with statutory interpretation.
The potential for further appeals or legislative intervention looms large. The IRS’s motion for reconsideration in Big Apple Tompkins Realty was denied, but the agency may seek relief from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit or push for legislative changes to codify its preferred interpretation of the BBA’s deadlines. The IRS’s argument that equitable tolling would undermine the BBA’s purpose is not without merit, and Congress could theoretically amend the statute to clarify that the 90-day deadline is jurisdictional. However, such a move would require bipartisan support and is unlikely in the near term. In the meantime, partnerships and their advisors must navigate this new landscape carefully. The Tax Court’s ruling does not create an open door for delay; it merely recognizes that the IRS, like all agencies, is not above reproach. Partnerships should still file petitions promptly and document all communications with the IRS, but they now have a procedural safeguard against the IRS’s own failures.
The fallout from this decision extends beyond individual cases. It reshapes the IRS’s audit strategy for partnerships, particularly those operating under the BBA. The agency can no longer rely on strict deadlines to dismiss late filings without scrutiny. Instead, the IRS must now consider whether its own errors or the taxpayer’s extraordinary circumstances justify equitable tolling. This shift may lead to more disputes over the sufficiency of IRS notices or the timeliness of its communications, but it also ensures that partnerships are not unfairly penalized for administrative failures beyond their control. The Tax Court’s decision in Big Apple Tompkins Realty is a reminder that the IRS’s power is not absolute, and that the judicial system remains the ultimate arbiter of tax disputes.
For partnerships, the message is clear: the BBA’s flexibility is a double-edged sword. While the 90-day deadline is no longer an absolute bar to judicial review, partnerships must still act diligently to preserve their rights. The court’s ruling does not excuse tardiness; it merely recognizes that the IRS’s failures can sometimes justify a second chance. The Tax Court’s power play in Big Apple Tompkins Realty is a reminder that in tax law, as in all areas of litigation, the rules are not set by the IRS alone. The judiciary remains the final check on administrative overreach, and the Tax Court has now reasserted that role with clarity.
News summaries on this site are generated with the assistance of artificial intelligence from primary source documents and are provided for educational purposes only. They are not legal advice and may contain errors; consult a qualified tax attorney about your situation and rely on the original source document. Communications are not protected by attorney client privilege until such relationship with an attorney is formed.
Related Cases
Siemens Medical Solutions USA, Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue: Tax Court Rejects IRS Limitation on Foreign Dividends Deduction
The stakes could not have been higher when Siemens Medical Solutions USA, Inc. and its consolidated subsidiaries squared off against the IRS in Tax Court this s
Eilers v. Commissioner: Full Settlement Proceeds Includible in Gross Income Despite Fee-Shifting Arguments
The Eilers’ $60,000 settlement under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) resulted in a $11,423 federal income tax liability.
John R. Dee v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
The Tax Court’s ruling in Dee delivers a dual message: a jurisdictional win for whistleblowers and a sharp reminder of the IRS’s unassailable discretion. After